PROVO UT - SEPTEMBER 1: Large signs hang outside Lavell Edwards Stadium where it was announced that BYU football will become independent in 2011 separating from the Mountain West Conference September 1 2010 in Provo Utah. The remaining BYU sports will become affiliated with the West Coast Conference in 2011. (Photo by George Frey/Getty Images)
Over the next several weeks, I'm going to reveal my rankings of the past 40 BYU football seasons (since 1972); call it the modern era of BYU football (or since LaVell). I did a similar thing last year, ranking every QB season since 1974.
This is a mix of qualitative and quantitative. I mainly considered the following:
- Winning. As Charlie Sheen might say, it's about winning.
- Quality. I used several things to measure this, including Sports-Reference.com's SRS* rating, which takes into account strength of schedule and average point differentiation. I also looked at opponents winning percentage and point differentials to get a good feel for how good each team really was.
- Impact. Teams got bonus points (and by points, I mean consideration in my head) for things like playing in a major bowl, being ranked highly, etc.
- Versus. If all else failed, I did the ridiculous mental exercise of pitting the two teams against each other deciding who would win.
As I mentioned, this is a highly qualitative exercise. Readers will likely disagree with many of my rankings, which is really the point.
The first ranking piece will come out on Thursday, the 5 worst BYU teams over the past 40 years. Any thoughts on the worst 5 teams of the past 40 years?